Offside is the rule that causes more arguments than any other in football. It decides big matches, it sits at the centre of many VAR reviews, and many fans who have watched the game for decades still find parts of it confusing.
The good news is that the core of the rule is fairly simple. The complications come from the details. Here is a full explanation, based on the current text of Law 11 from the International Football Association Board (IFAB), which writes the Laws of the Game.
Step one: the offside position
The first thing to understand is that being in an offside position is not an offence. A player can stand in an offside position all game without being penalised.
A player is in an offside position if both of these are true:
- Any part of their head, body or feet is in the opponents’ half (not counting the halfway line), and
- Any part of their head, body or feet is nearer to the opponents’ goal line than both the ball and the second-last opponent.
The second-last opponent is usually the last outfield defender, because the goalkeeper is normally the last opponent. But not always. If the goalkeeper has come out, the second-last opponent might be a defender on the goal line.
Two important details:
- Hands and arms don’t count. That applies to all players, including goalkeepers. IFAB defines the upper boundary of the arm as the bottom of the armpit.
- Level is onside. A player who is level with the second-last opponent, or with the last two opponents, is not in an offside position.
Step two: the offside offence
A player in an offside position is only penalised if, at the moment a team-mate plays or touches the ball, they become involved in active play. Law 11 lists three ways to do that:
- Interfering with play: playing or touching a ball passed or touched by a team-mate.
- Interfering with an opponent: for example, clearly blocking a goalkeeper’s line of vision, challenging an opponent for the ball, or clearly attempting to play a ball close by when that action impacts an opponent.
- Gaining an advantage: playing the ball, or interfering with an opponent, after it has rebounded or been deflected off the goalpost, crossbar, a match official or an opponent, or after an opponent has deliberately saved it.
The key moment is when the ball is played or touched by a team-mate. IFAB specifies that the first point of contact should be used, except when the ball is thrown by the goalkeeper, when the last point of contact is used.
When you can’t be offside
There is no offside offence if a player receives the ball directly from:
- a goal kick
- a throw-in
- a corner kick
The punishment for an offside offence is an indirect free kick to the defending team, taken from where the offence happened.
The tricky bit: deliberate play
The most confusing part of modern offside is what happens when a defender touches the ball before it reaches an attacker in an offside position.
If the defender deliberately played the ball, the attacker is not penalised. If the ball merely deflected off the defender, the attacker is still offside.
IFAB’s guidance lists the factors referees should consider when deciding whether a defender deliberately played the ball:
- Did the ball travel from a distance, and did the player have a clear view of it?
- Was the ball moving slowly?
- Was its direction expected?
- Did the player have time to coordinate their body movement, rather than instinctively stretching or jumping?
A ball moving along the ground is also considered easier to play than one in the air.
Crucially, a misplaced pass or failed clearance still counts as deliberate play. If a defender tries to pass back to the goalkeeper and gets it wrong, an attacker who was in an offside position can take advantage. A deliberate save, though, is treated differently: if a defender or goalkeeper stops a ball going into or very close to the goal, an attacker in an offside position who then plays the ball is penalised.
Technology: semi-automated offside
Offside decisions used to rely entirely on the assistant referee’s eyes. Then came VAR, with officials drawing lines on replays. Now many competitions use semi-automated offside technology, which uses multiple cameras to track players’ body positions and quickly generate a 3D image of the moment the ball is played.
The Premier League first used the technology on 12 April 2025, in Manchester City’s game against Crystal Palace, according to the Premier League. The main aim is speed. The system does not change the law, but it reduces the time officials spend drawing lines.
The daylight debate
Many fans feel that marginal offside calls, where an attacker is ruled off by a toenail or shoulder, go against the spirit of the rule. Arsène Wenger, FIFA’s chief of global football development, has long proposed a change: an attacker would only be offside if there is a complete gap, or “daylight”, between them and the second-last opponent.
According to the BBC, IFAB agreed in February 2026 that Wenger’s proposal would be trialled in the Canadian Premier League from April 2026, with the results to be presented at the end of the year. The BBC reported that the law could potentially change for the 2027/28 European season, although IFAB is likely to want more extensive trials first, not least because the Canadian league does not use VAR.
Our view
The current offside law is not broken. It is mostly clear, and the deliberate-play guidance, while complicated, has made decisions more consistent. The real problem is how precise technology has made it. When officials can measure offside to a few centimetres, decisions that are technically correct can feel wrong.
That is why the daylight trial matters. Giving the benefit of the doubt to attackers would mean more goals and fewer arguments about millimetres. Critics say it would hand too much advantage to the attacking team. We think it is worth trying properly, and the Canadian trial should only be the start.
Sources: IFAB Law 11, Premier League on semi-automated offside, BBC Sport.